| Name | Year | Split | Time |
| Derek Mead | 2007 | 1:39.6 | 4:59.0 |
| Theo Marquardt | 2023 | 1:41.8 | 5:05.4 |
| Noah Vriese | 2012 | 1:42.7 | 5:08.1 |
| Thomas Goeree | 2011 | 1:43.9 | 5:11.9 |
| Alex Papke | 2021 | 1:44.1 | 5:12.3 |
| Sam Whitsell | 2014 | 1:45.0 | 5:15.1 |
| Alex Fall | 2010 | 1:46.0 | 5:18.2 |
| Joe Buth | 2009 | 1:46.1 | 5:18.4 |